Real-Life Experience: My Personal Untamed Cat Food Reviews

Question

I’ve been trying out Untamed cat food lately (and also grabbed a few cans of 4health Untamed from Tractor Supply), so I wanted to hear what other cat owners think. I started with the Untamed wet cat food and then added some Untamed dry cat food into the rotation. My cats really liked the chicken and turkey recipes, especially the gravy ones bowls were wiped clean. 😻
I’ve seen a lot of mixed opinions online, especially on Reddit and Trustpilot, so I’m curious about real experiences. Has anyone noticed changes in energy, coat, digestion, or weight after switching to Untamed? And for those feeding 4health Untamed, how does it compare to Taste of the Wild or other grain-free brands?
I’m also wondering about the cost side

How much does Untamed cat food cost per month?
 Is it cheaper to buy through their site, Amazon, or in stores?
 Anyone using discount codes or subscription deals?

Also, does anyone know if Untamed cat food is raw or just high-meat cooked food? And where exactly is it made? I’ve found different answers.
Would love to hear honest reviews  wet food, dry food, good experiences, bad ones, anything helpful. Trying to decide if Untamed (or 4health Untamed) is really worth the price.

Feed Your Cat the Best with Untamed Cat Food!
High-quality meals loved by cats and trusted by owners.

Buy Now on Amazon

🥇 2139+ repeat purchases in 30 days!

felinenourishtime · Answer

I’ve had pretty good luck with 4health Untamed wet cat food, especially for my senior girl who can’t tolerate many canned foods. Taste of the Wild made her stool soft, but the 4health turkey formula didn’t. I’ve only bought Untamed cat food once when they had a discount code. It felt fancy, like Pure Cravings, but too expensive for long term. I spend around $50 a month on 4health and she’s thriving.

meowtreatsco · Answer

My cat is obsessed with the Untamed turkey wet food. The gravy looks thick and real, not jelly-like. But the dry food wasn’t her favorite unless I mixed a little Kirkland Signature kibble in. I asked their customer service about whether Untamed cat food is raw—they said no, it’s cooked. The label mentions high-meat content which explains the strong smell. It’s pricey though. I get the 4health Untamed turkey bags for daily feeding and save the Untamed trays for “special Sundays.

whiskernosh · Answer

I’m always cautious with new brands, but Untamed didn’t cause any stomach upsets for my two boys. Energy levels stayed the same. They preferred the chicken wet food over any of the dry options though. I saw mixed posts on Reddit too but decided to try anyway. Cost of Untamed per month for two cats was almost $120, which is wild. Switched back to Pure Cravings and Nature’s Domain because the budget matters, but Untamed definitely felt higher-quality.

purrmunchies · Answer

I wish Untamed wasn’t so expensive because my cat adored it. The gravy recipes especially. I tried buying through Amazon and it was a bit cheaper, but shipping was slower. Using their site subscription lowers the cost a bit, but still higher than Pure Cravings. Coat health improved noticeably though. I’ve been curious how many calories are in Untamed wet food it seems denser than most brands. 4health Untamed dry is what I use now and she does fine on it.

cattastenest · Answer

4health Untamed from Tractor Supply has been my budget lifesaver. The canned version feels close to Taste of the Wild’s quality but cheaper. I tried the actual Untamed wet cat food just once using a trial box, and it was definitely richer in texture, but I couldn’t justify the subscription. My cat didn’t seem more energetic or anything, but her digestion stayed smooth. Nutra Nuggets is still my favorite for price vs. value.