Forum Replies Created

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • CatPlateMate
    Participant

    I was curious about Thrive cat treats shrimp, and they did not disappoint. My cat usually avoids dry snacks, but these got her full attention. The texture is airy, crunchy, and easy to break for training rewards. I’ve used Kirkland Signature and Pure Cravings, but the natural ingredients in Thrive make a noticeable difference. Maxitube packaging keeps them fresh, and the portion size is perfect. Grain-free and high-protein, it’s a treat I feel good giving daily in moderation. My cats are definitely thriving on these snacks.

    CatPlateMate
    Participant

    I’ve been trying different canned foods, and the Almo Nature HFC variety pack is my cats’ newest obsession. The chicken breast and tuna natural wet options look so simple literally meat and broth. Compared to Pure Cravings or Kirkland Signature, Almo Nature feels lighter and less processed. I always check phosphorus levels since my senior cat struggles with kidney issues, and some flavors are definitely better than others. I usually order online unless I’m near the store that sells it locally. So far, digestion has been perfect.

    CatPlateMate
    Participant

    I reached out to the company last year asking who makes Triumph cat food, and they said it’s produced by Sunshine Mills. That explains the availability issues because Sunshine Mills has had supply chain problems before. I think that’s why some Triumph cat food 13.2 oz sizes disappeared. I’ve used Triumph canned cat food for years, though, and I’ve never seen a recall on the specific formulas I buy. Compared to Kirkland and Nature’s Domain, Triumph is more inconsistent but still decent when you get a “good batch.”

    CatPlateMate
    Participant

    I tried Fromm Four Star Gamebird Wet Cat Food for my indoor cat, and she’s hooked. Portioning is simple, and digestion has been smooth. Compared to Kirkland or Nature’s Domain, the ingredients feel premium and more specialized. I mix in a little dry Four Star Surf & Turf for texture, and she finishes everything happily. Her coat is shinier, litter box odors are less, and energy levels are up. It feels healthier and more balanced than most grocery store brands. Definitely worth trying if your cat is picky or needs premium nutrition.

    CatPlateMate
    Participant

    The Canadian manufacturing and ingredient sourcing gives me confidence. Champion Petfoods has excellent reputation for quality control. Acana being their mid-tier line means getting their quality standards at more accessible price than Orijen. The biologically appropriate approach makes sense for carnivores. Considering trying after hearing positive experiences.

    CatPlateMate
    Participant

    FANCY FEAST VS FRISKIES (affordable comparison)

    Both budget-friendly mass-market brands:

    Fancy Feast advantages:

    Better perceived quality reputation
    More variety of textures
    Smaller portions reduce waste
    Better marketing presence
    Slightly better ingredients some formulas

    Friskies advantages:

    Even more affordable pricing
    Larger can sizes available
    Good availability everywhere
    Adequate for very tight budgets
    Similar nutritional adequacy

    My view: Both provide adequate nutrition at affordable prices. Fancy Feast for slightly better quality perception. Friskies for maximum budget savings. Either works for healthy cats needing affordable food.

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
Scroll to Top