I’ve had almost the exact same experience with the lickable puree tubes. My cat usually walks away from Kirkland Signature, but with Fussie Cat treats she stays glued to the bowl. I’ve started using a small amount as a topper on Pure Cravings, and it completely changes her attitude toward meals. Chicken is still the favorite here, but tuna has been a nice backup when she gets bored. It’s honestly one of the few things that works every single time.