I’ve had almost the exact same experience with the bisque tubes. My cat usually takes her time with Kirkland Signature, but the second I open a Delectables tube, she’s fully locked in. Chicken seems to be her top choice, but tuna is a close second. I’ve also noticed they’re perfect for hiding meds or mixing into Pure Cravings when she’s being picky. The texture really makes a difference compared to crunchy treats. Definitely one of the easiest ways to get her excited about food.